Kaitlyn is a former professional wrestler best known for competing in WWE, where she briefly portrayed a villainess.
Kaitlyn debuted in 2010 as part of the all-Diva NXT competition, which she won. By 2011, she was one half of The Chickbusters with AJ Lee, and the pair feuded with the villainous Divas of Doom, which consisted of Beth Phoenix and Natalya. After a series of losses to the duo, Kaitlyn began turning villainous in November 2011, doing so by taking the losses out on AJ. After one loss on November 18, Kaitlyn scowled at AJ, showing little concern for her well being. A week later, Kaitlyn berated AJ after they again lost to the Divas of Doom, and left the ring right before AJ was attacked by Beth and Natalya.
Two weeks later on December 9, the evil Kaitlyn attacked AJ after they were again defeated by the Divas of Doom. After the attack, Kaitlyn cemented herself as a villainess and joined the Divas of Doom. However, since the segment was cut from the broadcast, Kaitlyn's heel turn was not recognized.
Kaitlyn returned to NXT in 2012, but in July of that year, Kaitlyn turned heel while appearing on the current modified version of NXT. In her first match as a villainess, Kaitlyn competed against Tamina Snuka, and displayed her villainous persona by laughing evilly at Tamina and hiding behind the official. Despite her heel character, Kaitlyn was defeated by Tamina. Three weeks later on August 8, Kaitlyn teamed with the evil Caylee Turner in a losing effort against Tamina and Paige, and on October 10, Kaitlyn teamed with Alicia Fox in a loss against Paige and Audrey Marie; Kaitlyn's last match as an NXT villainess.
Kaitlyn turned villainous once again on November 18, 2013; the final Raw before Survivor Series. All of the Divas participated in a game of Country Musical Chairs, which ended up with all of the women brawling. After the segment, Kaitlyn left with the heel Divas, and was shown snarling at the Total Divas cast, briefly cementing Kaityn's heel turn. At Survivor Series, Kaitlyn competed as part of the villainous True Divas team against the Total Divas cast; eliminating Eva Marie and Naomi in the match, only for her side to be defeated. Kaitlyn was on the losing side of a rematch the next night on Raw, but she again was on the villainous side of a five-on-five match a month later, this time emerging victorious.