For over two centuries, Mary haunted the exact location where she died, until she was summoned by Henry Parrish. In her ghostly "Weeping Lady" form, Mary killed Caroline, who made an advance at Ichabod, and tried to kill Abbie as well. She again tried to go after Katrina, but she managed to escape. In the episode's climax, Ichabod encountered Mary once again and attempted to get through to her, but to no avail. Mary was shot by Ichabod via a crossbow, and in her last gasp, the villainess attempted to go after Katrina and Abbie. Her curse was later lifted and she returned to human form. Before dying, Mary pointed towards Katrina as a response to Ichabod's query regarding her remaining at Sleepy Hollow, which led to Katrina confessing her indirect cause of Mary's first death.