Isabella is Charlie's Satan-worshipping girlfriend in the episode, and she is shown plaguing Alan with her practicing dark magic. She takes Alan's hair from his brush and threatens to place a curse on him. Alan mocks Isabella, only to end up nicking himself shaving--all the while, Isabella is heard laughing evilly. Regarding Charlie, Isabella introduced him to a coven of women as part of a plan to bring a Satanic spawn into the world. Just before the ritual is set to begin, Evelyn appears in her Halloween costume (the Wicked Witch of the West) and makes a veiled warning to Isabella, prompting the villainess to back off.
Isabella resurfaced as a haunting hallucination in Season Seven's "Gumby With a Pokey," and appeared as one of the many ex-girlfriends who attended Charlie's funeral in the anticipated Season Nine opener, "Nice to Meet You, Walden Schmidt."
- Jodi Lyn O'Keefe is arguably most famous for portraying bully Taylor Vaughan in the 1999 teen movie She's All That and Gretchen Morgan from Prison Break.
- Jodi Lyn O'Keefe's other villainous roles include serial killer Debbie Strand in Devil in the Flesh 2, vampiress Layla Simmons in Vampires: Out For Blood, tragic alternate reality villainess Gina Wright in A Nanny's Revenge, the evil Spider Demon on Charmed, wicked stepmother Lucy Lafleur on Eve, murderous femme fatale Lisa from The Finder, and bully Candace Aimes from Tru Calling.